Treasury Committee launches inquiry into QE

Bank of England governor Mark Carney

The UK’s Treasury Committee has launched an inquiry into the effectiveness and impact of post-2008 monetary policy in the UK.

Andrew Tyrie MP, chairman of the Treasury Committee, said: “Interest rates are stuck near zero, the Bank of England has used increasingly unconventional forms of quantitative easing (QE), and inflation has been below the two per cent target for three years.

“The efficacy of monetary policy or otherwise, its unintended consequences, and its prospects, need careful examination.”

Quantitative easing (QE) is an unconventional form of monetary policy where a central bank like the Bank of England creates new money electronically to buy financial assets like government bonds.

This process can result in lower interest rates and aims to stimulate the economy by leading to an increase in private sector spending in the economy and a return of inflation to a desired level.

“The Treasury committee will continue to act as a safeguard on the operational independence of the bank,” said Tyrie.

“The Treasury indemnity, which underpins parts of the bank’s monetary policy, could all too easily encourage the Treasury, or politicians, to put undue pressure on the bank.

“The committee will examine the risks of that, too.”

The committee said it has invited written submissions to address the following points:

  • The effectiveness of holding bank rate near zero and whether extremely low rates can encourage more, rather than less, saving
  • The effectiveness of quantitative easing and whether it has met with diminishing returns
  • The scope for further expansion of “qualitative easing” (e.g. corporate bond purchases)
  • Whether forward guidance effectively binds the bank to a policy course, and the desirability of doing so
  • The impact on asset-price inflation, the housing market and financial stability
  • The implications for the long-term sustainability of pensions and savings income
  • The distributional impact
  • The impact on competition, “zombie companies” and productivity
  • The effects on the structure of relative prices in capital and commodity markets and the consequences for capital allocation, productivity and the trade cycle
  • The implications of a large balance sheet and the Treasury indemnity for Bank accountability and its relationship with the government and other agencies
  • The use of macro-prudential, fiscal and other policy to counterbalance any unintended consequences of monetary policy
  • The drivers behind and prospects for low real interest rates in the UK and globally
  • What is the significance for monetary policy of rises in bond yields since the US election?
  • The impact and trade-offs of tightening monetary policy in the near-term
  • Whether monetary policy is currently out of ammunition for the next crisis
  • Options for raising the “natural rate” of interest (e.g. fiscal policy, promoting investment)