Scottish Investment Trust warns on meme stocks

Ally McKinnon, manager, Scottish Investment Trust

The £677 million Scottish Investment Trust plc (SIT) has warned that making stock market investments based on the influence of a “new generation of self-appointed pundits” on social media is “equivalent to gambling on a horse that has an ‘interesting name’.”

The fund said the self-appointed pundits are “giving financial advice on social media to attract followers and income.”

The trust said that while the “democratisation of investing” is positive “the way in which investment ideas are conveyed through online social channels is not always comprehensive.”

The Scottish Investment Trust, a contrarian closed-end fund managed by Ally McKinnon, said in a post entitled “The Rise of Pop Investing Culture: “There’s no ignoring the rise of influencer culture – even for those people who have no desire to keep up with the Kardashians, or watch K-pop on TikTok.

“What’s interesting, however, is that influencers are branching out from the realms of entertainment and fashion into the world of personal finance and investing.

“Put simply, a new generation of self-appointed pundits is giving financial advice on social media to attract followers and income.

“While the democratisation of investing is a positive, the way in which investment ideas are conveyed through online social channels is not always comprehensive.

“Social platforms’ algorithms favour short and sharp messages from charismatic presenters highlighting all that’s appealing or trending.

“So the words ‘safe’, ‘guaranteed returns’ and ‘instantly’ have entered the jargon commonly used among millennial and Z-er investors.

“According to a recent survey by Charles Schwab, 15% of participants in US markets have invested for the first time during the last year.

“Government-fuelled stimulus allowed stockmarkets to stage a strong recovery from the lows of early 2020, presenting new investors with the false impression that making gains is always this ‘quick’ and ‘easy’ …

“Of course, even professional investors aren’t immune to herd behaviour, but they are at least educated on the risks.

“Having seen the side-effects of crowd mentality, asset booms and busts, they also know how human emotions can influence investing and more than try to stay dispassionate.

“Experienced investors are also more likely to have a defined ‘sell’ discipline, often outlining in advance the circumstances that would trigger a sale.

“These are important considerations that may not always be given thought by day traders using platforms such as Robinhood.

“The very name is predicated on taking money from the rich to give to the poor: a clear play on investors’ emotions.

“It taps into the human psyche – they too can access a service that’s usually seen as reserved for the well off.

“Such platforms are adept at selling themselves to new audiences that are more at home with YouTube and TikTok than the FT, with users sometimes investing student loans rather than pension pots …”

On June 21, Scottish Investment Trust said its net asset value per share (NAV) total return was 14.4% over the half year to April 30, 2021.

The contrarian global fund’s share price increased from 681p to 780p during the period which, including dividends, meant that the share price total return was 16.4%.

On June 2, the board of the Scottish Investment Trust announced a review of the future investment management arrangements of the company.

The closed-end fund said any proposals will be considered alongside its current management “which the board notes have delivered strong recent short-term performance.”

As of April 30, 2021, Edinburgh-based SIT managed assets of £677 million. The trust has a stock market value of around £515 million.

On the potential dangers of social media on investing, the fund added: “Analysing prospective investments is not glamorous work.

“It involves scouring the company’s financials – looking at cashflows, profits and the ability to pay dividends among others.

“Then there’s qualitative research – investigating or meeting management and examining how stakeholders such as employees or the supply chain are treated.

“It’s essential background data, but probably wouldn’t make a riveting TikTok video.

“When an investment is chosen by word-of-mouth on social media, relying purely on an exciting story, it’s equivalent to gambling on a horse that has an ‘interesting name’.

“It might be a winner, but without looking into the fundamentals or its long-term prospects, it is effectively a punt.

“Instead, there’s no better way to start investing than learning about the essentials first.

“And there’s nothing wrong with using the innovative apps and tools available – far from it.

“However, it’s vital that choices are researched thoroughly, weighing up the pros and cons of a potential investment before it is made.

“So it’s not just a punt, but a decision that can prove financially rewarding into the future.”

About the Author

Mark McSherry
Dalriada Media LLC sites are edited by veteran news journalist Mark McSherry, a former staff editor and reporter with Reuters, Bloomberg and major newspapers including the South China Morning Post, London's Sunday Times and The Scotsman. McSherry's journalism has also appeared in The Washington Post, The Guardian, The Independent, The New York Times, London's Evening Standard and Forbes. McSherry is also a professor of journalism and communication arts in universities and colleges in New York City. Scottish-born McSherry has an MBA from the University of Edinburgh and a Certificate in Global Affairs from New York University.